| User | DQ'd? | Judge 1 | Judge 2 | Judge 3 | Judge 4 | Final Average | User Votes | ||
| Sockbat Replica | D | C | D | B | C | Favorites | A | ||
| Hadron | B | D | D | A | C | Enjoyible | B | ||
| Purple Rex | A | B | B | A | A-B | 5 | Ambivalent | C | |
| GammaV | B | B | B | A | B | Unfulfilling | D | ||
| Javier | D | F | F | D | D-F | Not For me | F | ||
| SilverSwallow | B | B | B | B | B | ||||
| DoopyBuckride | F | D | B | C | C-D | ||||
| GlitchMr. | F | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Sokobansolver | D | F | F | D | D-F | 1 | |||
| luigiman09 | F | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Ladida | F | C | C | D | D | 1 | |||
| KY2010 | F | F | C | C | D | ||||
| Notgoodwithusernames | B | B | A | A | A-B | 2 | |||
| AirMario | D | F | C | F | D | ||||
| Morsel | C | C | C | A | B-C | ||||
| Shog | C | D | B | C | C | ||||
| MagiLuigi | B | D | C | C | C | ||||
| Aquamentus | C | C | C | C | C | 1 | |||
| ShadowPhoenix | C | D | B | A | B-C | 4 | |||
| Yan | D | D | B | C | C | 3 | |||
| Thy | B | F | B | B | C | 3 | |||
| Punk Sarcopagus | B | C | B | A | B | ||||
| MarioFan22 | B | C | B | A | B | ||||
| yogui | D | D | C | D | D | ||||
| Levelengine | C | D | D | A | C | ||||
| Hawthorne | D | C | C | D | C-D | ||||
| Dark Mario Bros | X | F | F | C | D | D | |||
| Mr. Blue Yoshi | F | C | F | D | D | ||||
| tjdtnsu | X | F | D | C | D | D | |||
| ShadowFire | D | F | B | A | C | ||||
| BlueLeaf | B | B | A | A | A-B | 1 | |||
| Dakress | D | B | A | A | A-B | 1 | |||
| Zmann | B | C | B | B | B | ||||
| Mariosyoshishade | F | D | C | B | C-D | ||||
| Everest700 | C | C | C | C | C | ||||
| Carld923 | B | B | B | A | B | 1 | |||
| HyperMario | C | D | B | C | C | ||||
| Archie | B | F | B | A | B-C | ||||
| 1UpDudes | D | C | B | A | B-C | ||||
| ferrety | B | A | B | A | A-B | 4 | |||
| Guinimo | F | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Ripperon-X | D | F | D | D | D | ||||
| kenny | D | D | C | B | C | ||||
| PatPatPat | C | D | C | A | C | ||||
| Undy | B | D | B | A | B | 4 | |||
| TomPhanto | B | B | B | B | B | ||||
| Snifit | B | B | A | A | A-B | ||||
| PowerNewTop | - | D | B | D | |||||
| Hobz | - | D | C | A | 2 | ||||
| EvilGuy | B | D | B | A | B | ||||
| chineesmw | X | F | F | C | D | D | |||
| GloomyStar | B | C | B | A | B | 2 | |||
| Caraccs | F | F | C | B | D | ||||
| Lemonade | D | C | B | A | B-C | ||||
| FPZerp & Teyla | B | B | A | A | A-B | 1 | |||
| Hielus | B | A | C | A | B | ||||
| Koopster | B | D | B | B | B-C | 1 | |||
| Egadd | D | F | C | C | D | ||||
| bokuNES | X | F | F | D | F | F | |||
| FrankyC253 | F | F | F | C | D-F | ||||
| K1nghacks | D | D | C | D | D | ||||
| Burst Man | F | C | C | F | D | ||||
| Jonny | D | C | C | D | C-D | 1 | |||
| RealMariGamer | F | F | F | D | F | ||||
| The Secret Exit | F | F | B | D | D | ||||
| Amida | F | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Mariocool1999 | D | D | B | D | C-D | ||||
| Ragey | B | D | A | B | B | ||||
| Someguy712x | A | F | B | B | B-C | ||||
| Findoku29 | F | F | F | F | F | ||||
| Dazio Dee Von | X | D | C | C | D | C-D | |||
| neosaver | C | C | B | C | C | ||||
| Dphoenix | C | D | B | B | C | 1 | |||
| Poloros | F | D | C | A | C | ||||
| Oh Hell No | D | D | B | C | C | 1 | |||
| Masterlink & MaxodeX | C | C | B | C | C | 2 | |||
| 678ruby678 | X | F | F | F | F | F | |||
| Lui37 | D | D | B | B | C | ||||
| X-cniS | F | F | C | F | D-F | ||||
| tatanga | X | F | C | D | D | D | |||
| Pikerchu13 | D | C | D | D | D | 1 | |||
| NoelYoshi & Incognito | B | D | B | C | C | 3 | |||
| LuigiTime | X | F | F | F | F | F |