ExGFX RESULTS
Foreground Style+50 Rate the Style of the graphics from 0-50: 50-41=Favorites, 40-31=Enjoyible, 30-21=Ambivalent, 20-11=Unfulfilling, 10-0=Not for Me Background +10 Automatic 10 points for including a BG Background Style+15 If BG was included, rate 0-15 for style: 15-12=Favorites, 11-9=Enjoyible, 8-6=Ambivalent, 5-3=Unfulfilling, 2-0=Not for Me Originality +10 0 if standard, +5 if semi original, +10 for full on original (only enter 0, 5 or 10) File Perfection +15 -5 for every missing object
Lightvayne's Reviews
Name	FG Style	BG	BG Style	Originality	File Perfection	Total	Additional Notes
Aquamentus	31	10	12	5	15	73	Great tile set. Love the background, though I wish there was a bit more variety to it, it tiles a lot more than it should. The FG is nice, but the perspective look all wrong with the street.
Carld923	45	10	14	10	15	94	I love this set and the twist you gave it but giving it a Park feeling. Great Decorations, with the trees, stop signs and other various details and I like how you did kind of a sewer entrance for the street. Excellent Job.
Gloomy Star	40	10	10	10	15	85	Excellent set. I think the part I love the most of the animation for the electricity and some of the detail surrounding it. I feel the buildings however lack of bit of details themselves Also it feels like it missing corner tiles above and around the sewer area.
Guilherme F Santos	15	10	4	5	15	49	The style to me is very flat and single toned. Depending on the style you are going for, its fine though. But this also seems to lack decoration. The bg's tiles very close together and could have been changed up a bit, same goes for the FG
Hinalyte	35	0	0	10	15	60	Not bad overall, a bit disappointed it didn't come with a BG, even at the very least a default one from SMW. The Decorations aren't bad, and its the first time I've seen someone draw a highway (seen at the upper portion of the first screen, Would have like to see some slopes to it.
Ladida	48	10	8	10	15	91	This is a great tileset, you nailed the 3d Pseudo FG, I love the details with the decoration. I think the layer 3 BG (not shown in pic) could have went a little better, it just seems to lack the detail expected with the FG.
Level ASMer	31	0	3	5	15	54	Pretty good set. Simple enough that some of it could be used for a castle tileset also. I liked the vending machine and It would have been nice to see a BG.
PokerFace	35	0	8	10	15	68	A pretty decent set, though even though it is city theme, I would of likes to be a bit more color and variation in the colors....a lot of gray currently. The star BG goes nice with it, but would have like to see some building in the BG too.
S.R.H.	27	10	8	5	15	65	Wow, that's blue :V Not a bad set, I like the simplicity of the bg, though its the FG that could have used a bit more decoration
SuperAgentYoshi	0	10	3	0	5	18	Yeah, you obviously did something wrong with your map16 page, not to mention you didn't even includes a FG -_-. I took a look at the exgfx file that came with it, it looks pretty good overall, but could have used more decoration to it.
Wuthering	43	10	14	10	15	92	Another Great city Park theme. I loves the details of the fence and bushes
Tahixham's Reviews
Name	FG Style	BG	BG Style	Originality	File Perfection	Total	Additional Notes
Aquamentus	37	10	12	10	15	84	Nice idea with it actually being about SMWC. The road looks a bit weird in it's perspective, but I like the rest.
Carld923	40	10	11	5	15	81	This was also a nice one. The trees looked a bit square to me, though.
Gloomy Star	34	10	9	5	15	73	The background is in quite a simple style, but I like it. I also quite like the FG, too.
Guilherme F Santos	28	10	7	0	15	60	The cartoony style is OK. But not everything looked great, like the trees. Overall, though, it was alright.
Hinalyte	39	0	0	10	15	64	I like the variety in decorations and so on. The style of the FG looks nice too, Silly Goose!
Ladida	49	10	7	10	15	91	3D stuff is always the best, and I love this one. Nice to see something set in like a park of a city, instead of the main city. BG is fairly basic though, but then again not everything is capable with layer 3.
Level ASMer	30	0	0	0	15	45	I feel a BG would have done you wonders here, I really liked the FG but wasn't getting the city vibe, to be honest.
PokerFace	32	0	0	5	15	52	I like the night time theme here. The grey of the buildings is a nice effect.
S.R.H.	29	10	10	0	15	64	It's quite good, to be honest. Some parts of the FG are better than others, I like the house. The blue everywhere is a bit, weird. The BG is probably my favorite part of it, simple, but nice.
SuperAgentYoshi	0	10	5	0	5	20	The map16 page doesn't work, so I looked at the BIN file with the palette instead. I'm going to assume it's just a tower? It looked like it needs more shading, the style is OK but not great.
Wuthering	48	10	14	10	15	97	This one: love it! I love the look of everything here. Great job!
Contest Entree	Score 1	Score 2	Final
Wuthering	92	97	94.5	1st Place
Ladida	91	91	91	2nd Place
Carld923	94	81	87.5	3rd Place
Gloomy Star	85	73	79
Aquamentus	73	84	78.5
S.R.H.	65	64	64.5
Hinalyte	60	64	62
PokerFace	68	52	60
Guilherme F Santos	49	60	54.5
Level ASMer	54	45	49.5
SuperAgentYoshi	18	20	19