ExGFX Contest Results: Hinalyte
User	FG Style	BG	BG Style	Originality	File Perfection	Total	Additional Notes
levelengine	30	No	8	5	0	58	FG Style: Looks good for a cave tileset. Your art is okay, but I feel like it lacks more decorations. The palette animation doesn't feel right to me. The rocks on the mushrooms look out of place for some reason. BG: N/A BG Style: The background that you chose fits with your graphics. Originality: A crystal cave is something common, but adding a minecart element is a plus. File Perfection: N/A Overall: This is a decent crystal cave tileset. Good job!
Rykon-V73	40	Yes	12	6	0	83	FG Style: I can't capture the "wood" feel on this, it's more like a stone. Anyways, this looks very detailed. The signs were a nice touch, but I still think it need more decorations than that. Also the animated spikes look odd. BG: N/A BG Style: The background looks nice and fits with the FG very well. Originality: A castle is also something common, no matter how it looks like, but this looks more different compared to most castle tilesets. File Perfection: N/A Overall: A great castle tileset. Would work on some puzzle levels.
Superkingyoshi	34	Yes	9	6	3	59	FG Style: Not bad, but maybe some more variation would be nice. The pillars are a nice addition for a decoration on a cave tileset, it makes me think I'm inside a cavern of a ruins. BG: N/A BG Style: Kind of clashy, but it works with your FG. The color reminds me of chocolate. Originality: Cave again, but the addition of the pillars made me think it's not just your usual cave. File Perfection: I'm sorry but you messed up big time here. First you submitted a .rar file, then the palette file and sample level's palettes doesn't match. And, the map16, it feels like you forgot to put the correct Act Like/Priority settings. Also missing a single tile. Overall: Would be a good usage after a ruins level.
2dareduck	9	Yes	8	6	1	43	FG Style: A different foreground this time! But, it doesn't really look appealing for me, adding that it's really limited. The 3D-ish look worked well with your tileset though. BG: N/A BG Style: Am I inside a box? It looks plain but I guess that can't be helped. Originality: It looks like an active factory, but inside a box... haven't seen this before; it's quite an odd idea. File Perfection: > .ips file instead of sample level Overall: I didn't enjoyed much on the tileset, sorry.
yogui	3	No	0	1	0	19	FG Style: The random sketches reminded me of some computer-cyberspace something. BG: N/A BG Style: rgb(0,0,0) Originality: I lost my words on this. File Perfection: > no error Overall: 10/10 would use
MetaKnight 3	25	Yes	8	6	0	64	FG Style: It needs more details, shading and stuff. The combination of the 3D-ish look and the 2D ones look odd. Good idea for a tileset, but I felt like it needs more of it. BG: N/A BG Style: Given that it's the same graphics as the FG, it can tend to be confusing, even when given with a darker color. The clouds reminds me of SMB1 for some reason. Originality: A treehouse tileset isn't really that common compared to forest tilesets. File Perfection: N/A Overall: I liked the idea of the tileset, but I think it wasn't fully made.
Daizo Dee Von	31	Yes	8	7	0	71	FG Style: Looks nicely detailed. I don't know if you'd need more decorations, but that feels kind of unrealistic to see that a watermelon having tons of stuff being inserted on it. BG: N/A BG Style: So a watermelon castle? Interesting. Originality: More originality because no one haven't made an inside-food tileset. File Perfection: N/A Overall: This would work on some fruit-themed world or something similar.
Gloomy Star	44	Yes	12	8	0	89	FG Style: Oh, this one looks cute~. The main FG doesn't really have much to showoff, but there are some good amount of decorations to see on the tileset. This is a pretty tileset! BG: N/A BG Style: Cute one too. Properly detailed and stuff. It matches with the FG. Also I found an SMW portrait there (I wonder what's the thing inside the pillar). Originality: Mario's Room, while limited on environment, can be made with lots of graphic ideas to work with. File Perfection: N/A Overall: This is a pretty tileset to be used on your Mario's Room level (but what about Luigi?).
LuigiTime	27	Yes	8	6	0	66	FG Style: Didn't get quite much the appeal. I like the falling yellow lava effect, but I don't think it should just fall down out of nowhere like that. Also the tileset's pattern is more like a bonus room. BG: N/A BG Style: It also reminds me of a bonus room rather than a factory tileset. The candle looks randomly slapped on the BG considering that it doesn't have anything on it. Originality: I don't know what kind of tileset is this; it looks like a factory, and they're not really common. File Perfection: N/A Overall: Looks like it only has a little use.
Ladida	43	Yes	8	9	0	85	FG Style: It feels like you're venturing on a giant classroom. It looks so creative, like how the tables look like as slopes, chalk-drawn muncher being actually able to hurt you, and lots more. It feels lively with these things around. BG: N/A BG Style: Sensei is staring at her giant classroom. I don't know what's up with the "Mumble" (or whatever's the translation of ほにャらら), but the BG feels kind of off with the FG. Originality: This is quite some original idea that we have here. File Perfection: N/A Overall: I would love to study on this classroo- er I mean this is a silly yet great tileset to work with.
Wuthering	44	Yes	10	9	0	88	FG Style: I like how this one looks like; nicely detailed. The palette looks like it's been covered with some cream. The only thing I noticed that it doesn't have any decorations included at all. BG: N/A BG Style: Looks simple, but works with your FG. It could use some more background stuffs, I don't know - it fits greatly. Originality: "Crystal Castle" - I was expecting a castle filled with crystal decorations, but I can't find the crystal part other than the background. Still an original idea you had though. File Perfection: N/A Overall: Nicely drawn castle tileset! Would work out on your ice world's castle levels.
S.R.H.	38	Yes	10	8	0	81	FG Style: The colors fit very well with your tileset, but the palette animation doesn't look good with the crates and stuff. Most of your FG looks great, but I also felt it needs more of it, given that you still have space on your ExGFX file. BG: N/A BG Style: Oh, the darkness of the BG fits very well with your FG. I think the shadow is too much but that's all I'd comment on. Originality: A factory, even a somewhat common tileset, is rarely drawn. Yours look promising for this kind of tileset. File Perfection: N/A Overall: I'd like to see more on this tileset. You've done a great job on this.
Snifit	35	Yes	9	8	0	77	FG Style: Interesting tileset. I find it funny that you climb on a toilet paper. I don't know if the ExAnimation inside the pipes look great though. Still, it's detailed so good job about that. BG: N/A BG Style: Filled with Boos! Reminds me of something, but that fits with the idea that you're going - "Haunted Restroom". Originality: A restroom tileset is really rare to see. File Perfection: N/A Overall: This would work out on a Ghost House's sublevels.
Deeke	37	Yes	10	6	1	73	FG Style: Another one with a 3D-ish look. I like how the tileset looks like, but I don't think it would work out with SMW's objects given it's 3D-ish look. Still a great job on your tileset though. BG: N/A BG Style: I like the background. It looks great along with the FG. It looks greatly detailed too. Originality: Castle tilesets are common, but a plus for giving it a 3D-ish look. File Perfection: Map16 Act Like settings; some Act Like 25 when it's supposed to be 130. Overall: You've done well on your tileset.
Carld923	34	Yes	9	8	0	76	FG Style: Greatly detailed. Kind of clashes with SMW's tileset (given it's shading and outlines). I don't know if you need more decorations on your tileset. BG: N/A BG Style: Creepy but detailed, and works well with your BG. Originality: I don't know how to explain this tileset, it looks like a cave or or a gum or inside of something. File Perfection: N/A Overall: I don't know how are people going to use this. We'll see.